1
00:00:00,251 --> 00:00:01,877
[Jessica] Tonight on Murder, She Wrote.

2
00:00:02,920 --> 00:00:04,296
He was in bed
with another man's wife.

3
00:00:04,463 --> 00:00:07,591
This case is not
as simple as it seems.

4
00:00:07,675 --> 00:00:09,885
This is a man's life
we're deciding.

5
00:00:09,969 --> 00:00:12,847
And most of us here are
of a mind to let him keep it.

6
00:00:12,930 --> 00:00:15,099
This jury has just
been hung by this...

7
00:00:15,182 --> 00:00:16,767
gentleman with the open mind.

8
00:00:16,851 --> 00:00:20,062
Hey, we're 12 reasonably
intelligent people here.

9
00:00:20,146 --> 00:00:21,272
We ought to be able
to sort this thing out.

10
00:00:21,355 --> 00:00:23,983
If it wasn't premeditated,
then it had to be self defense.

11
00:00:24,066 --> 00:00:24,900
There's nothing else.

12
00:00:24,984 --> 00:00:26,444
But there is something else.

13
00:00:26,527 --> 00:00:27,903
Ladies and gentlemen
of the jury,

14
00:00:27,987 --> 00:00:29,947
-have you reached a verdict?
-We have, your honor.

15
00:01:22,082 --> 00:01:23,125
[police radio chatter]

16
00:01:23,834 --> 00:01:25,211
Get-get through.

17
00:01:34,261 --> 00:01:35,346
Get through.

18
00:01:40,142 --> 00:01:41,811
Watch out.
Watch out. Easy.

19
00:01:46,232 --> 00:01:48,776
Careful. Watch it.

20
00:01:48,859 --> 00:01:51,737
Careful, now.

21
00:01:51,821 --> 00:01:53,322
I'm all right.
I'm all right.

22
00:01:53,405 --> 00:01:55,407
-Take care of her.
-Don't move.

23
00:01:58,410 --> 00:02:01,080
[groaning]

24
00:02:02,832 --> 00:02:06,126
Use that wrecker
to get that car out of here now.

25
00:02:07,586 --> 00:02:09,088
I should have made her
wear the seat belt.

26
00:02:09,171 --> 00:02:10,506
I should've made her.

27
00:02:10,589 --> 00:02:12,299
She never wanted to wear her
seat belt.

28
00:02:12,383 --> 00:02:14,093
She always felt like
she was gonna be trapped.

29
00:02:14,176 --> 00:02:18,055
Babe, I'm sorry.
I'm so sorry.

30
00:02:18,138 --> 00:02:20,307
Oh, she's not--
she's not going to die, is she?

31
00:02:20,391 --> 00:02:22,810
Steph, I'm sorry.

32
00:02:22,893 --> 00:02:25,187
She isn't gonna die, is she?

33
00:02:25,271 --> 00:02:29,525
[groans]
I don't understand.

34
00:02:30,734 --> 00:02:32,278
-Why?
-It was the kid.

35
00:02:32,361 --> 00:02:33,737
It was the kid on the bike.

36
00:02:33,821 --> 00:02:36,824
I swerved to avoid him.
Oh, my God.

37
00:02:42,454 --> 00:02:43,956
It was my fault.

38
00:02:49,795 --> 00:02:51,630
Oh, it should have been me.
It should have been me.

39
00:02:51,714 --> 00:02:53,048
When can I talk to her?

40
00:02:53,132 --> 00:02:55,467
Well, we'll know more
about that in the morning.

41
00:02:55,551 --> 00:02:58,345
The paramedic said
you fractured your collarbone.

42
00:02:58,429 --> 00:03:00,055
No, it's all right.
I'm all right.

43
00:03:00,139 --> 00:03:01,265
All right.

44
00:03:01,974 --> 00:03:03,225
Well, if you'd
like to be with her--

45
00:03:03,309 --> 00:03:05,227
No, no, I can't--
I can't look at her

46
00:03:05,311 --> 00:03:06,812
knowing that I'm the one that--

47
00:03:06,896 --> 00:03:08,105
I understand that.

48
00:03:08,188 --> 00:03:10,107
Well, if she does
regain consciousness,

49
00:03:10,190 --> 00:03:11,817
it won't be for,
oh, several hours.

50
00:03:13,235 --> 00:03:14,403
Look, Mr. Reynolds,

51
00:03:14,486 --> 00:03:17,573
your wife has a good chance
of surviving,

52
00:03:17,656 --> 00:03:19,366
but, well, I'm afraid
she may never walk again.

53
00:03:19,950 --> 00:03:21,619
There was severe spinal damage.

54
00:03:21,702 --> 00:03:23,746
-I'm sorry.
-Oh, my God.

55
00:03:24,246 --> 00:03:26,248
-Oh, my God!
-Mr. Reynolds!

56
00:03:37,509 --> 00:03:38,636
Oh, wow!

57
00:03:38,719 --> 00:03:40,220
Hey, pal,
you been in an accident?

58
00:03:40,304 --> 00:03:42,014
Give me a shot
of scotch, will ya?

59
00:03:42,097 --> 00:03:44,642
Are you sure you're all right?

60
00:03:44,725 --> 00:03:47,186
Hey, Jerry,
give me a clean towel, okay?

61
00:03:48,312 --> 00:03:51,774
You look awful.
What happened?

62
00:03:51,857 --> 00:03:54,276
-He called it-- Accident.
-Anybody else hurt?

63
00:03:54,360 --> 00:03:56,862
Yeah.
Someone else was hurt.

64
00:03:59,031 --> 00:04:01,659
It was my--

65
00:04:16,340 --> 00:04:18,592
This little kid was so scared.

66
00:04:18,676 --> 00:04:20,427
I mean, I missed him by--
by that.

67
00:04:21,804 --> 00:04:24,056
And he just took off
and never looked back.

68
00:04:24,139 --> 00:04:25,849
If my wife lives,

69
00:04:25,933 --> 00:04:28,060
the doctor said
she'll never walk again.

70
00:04:28,143 --> 00:04:29,895
And I did it to her.

71
00:04:29,979 --> 00:04:30,980
No, you can't think that.

72
00:04:33,816 --> 00:04:35,401
Who's that
with Becky Anderson?

73
00:04:35,484 --> 00:04:36,986
What'll it be, Mr. Detweiler?

74
00:04:37,069 --> 00:04:39,613
She's a pip, isn't she?

75
00:04:39,697 --> 00:04:41,740
Her old man would be
climbin' the walls if--

76
00:04:41,824 --> 00:04:43,951
Look, the guy was
in an automobile accident.

77
00:04:44,034 --> 00:04:45,202
His wife was almost killed.

78
00:04:45,285 --> 00:04:46,745
Now, can I get you somethin'?

79
00:04:46,829 --> 00:04:48,831
Yeah, a beer.

80
00:04:56,046 --> 00:04:57,756
You know,
I used to race sports cars.

81
00:04:57,840 --> 00:05:00,426
And Stephanie
used to come watch me.

82
00:05:00,509 --> 00:05:02,803
I should've been able
to handle that spin-out.

83
00:05:02,886 --> 00:05:04,763
Now, you've got to stop
blamin' yourself.

84
00:05:04,847 --> 00:05:07,307
No, an automobile's
a dangerous thing.

85
00:05:07,391 --> 00:05:08,350
You know,
I always buckled up.

86
00:05:08,434 --> 00:05:09,518
She never did.

87
00:05:09,601 --> 00:05:11,311
Your wife would be
the last person

88
00:05:11,395 --> 00:05:14,064
to blame you for what happened.

89
00:05:15,274 --> 00:05:16,316
Thanks.

90
00:05:19,486 --> 00:05:20,654
Oh, my gosh.
Look at the time.

91
00:05:20,738 --> 00:05:22,823
-I've got to go.
-Oh.

92
00:05:23,824 --> 00:05:25,868
Can I drive you
back to the hospital?

93
00:05:25,951 --> 00:05:27,202
Oh, no, no.
That's the last thing I--

94
00:05:27,286 --> 00:05:29,538
I can't face my wife
until the morning.

95
00:05:31,749 --> 00:05:33,417
Could a friendly
neighborhood stranger

96
00:05:33,500 --> 00:05:35,044
offer to make you
a cup of coffee?

97
00:05:35,127 --> 00:05:36,712
No, thanks.

98
00:05:38,047 --> 00:05:42,801
Well, as a matter of fact,
I'd be very grateful.

99
00:05:46,680 --> 00:05:48,766
-Good night, Becky.
-Good night.

100
00:05:48,849 --> 00:05:50,059
Thanks.

101
00:06:13,665 --> 00:06:15,918
Ah, well,
ain't that somethin'?

102
00:06:16,001 --> 00:06:17,878
What's that, Mr. Detweiler?

103
00:06:17,961 --> 00:06:20,047
Well,
if I were to give it a name,

104
00:06:20,130 --> 00:06:22,466
I'd call it the sympathy jump
in the making.

105
00:06:22,549 --> 00:06:24,510
I didn't see nothin'.

106
00:06:24,593 --> 00:06:26,220
Open me one more,
Jerry, will ya?

107
00:06:26,303 --> 00:06:27,304
I'll be right back.

108
00:06:36,772 --> 00:06:38,899
[phone ringing]

109
00:06:43,695 --> 00:06:44,780
Yeah?

110
00:06:44,863 --> 00:06:46,240
Yeah, Willie?
Johnny Detweiler.

111
00:06:46,323 --> 00:06:47,449
Cliff still stayin' with you?

112
00:06:47,699 --> 00:06:49,243
Yeah.

113
00:06:49,326 --> 00:06:50,661
Detweiler.

114
00:06:55,374 --> 00:06:58,335
[sighs]
Hello, creep, what's new?

115
00:07:01,380 --> 00:07:02,548
What are you talkin' about?

116
00:07:02,631 --> 00:07:05,717
Real good lookin',
got-rocks type.

117
00:07:05,801 --> 00:07:06,927
She's takin' him home now.

118
00:07:12,391 --> 00:07:13,976
What'd he call for?

119
00:07:14,726 --> 00:07:16,186
Becky's picked up some guy.

120
00:07:16,270 --> 00:07:17,521
What?

121
00:07:17,604 --> 00:07:19,815
Trial separation, she says.

122
00:07:19,898 --> 00:07:22,192
I'm gonna kill that broad!

123
00:07:23,610 --> 00:07:25,737
[gavel pounding]

124
00:07:25,821 --> 00:07:27,614
Ladies and gentlemen
of the jury,

125
00:07:27,698 --> 00:07:29,533
you have heard the evidence.

126
00:07:30,117 --> 00:07:33,120
And the time has come for you
to deliberate on your verdict.

127
00:07:34,121 --> 00:07:38,041
It is your sworn duty
to determine if the defendant,

128
00:07:38,125 --> 00:07:39,918
Mark Lee Reynolds,

129
00:07:40,002 --> 00:07:41,712
is guilty,
as the prosecution charges,

130
00:07:41,795 --> 00:07:43,922
of criminal homicide,

131
00:07:44,006 --> 00:07:46,383
or, as the defense contends,
innocent,

132
00:07:47,301 --> 00:07:49,136
in that he killed
Clifford Anderson

133
00:07:49,219 --> 00:07:50,929
in self-defense.

134
00:07:51,013 --> 00:07:54,558
Now, your responsibility
is to so determine,

135
00:07:54,641 --> 00:07:57,686
based solely on the evidence
and testimony presented.

136
00:07:58,353 --> 00:08:00,606
And when you are in accordance,
madam foreman,

137
00:08:00,689 --> 00:08:02,608
you shall deliver
your verdict to the court.

138
00:08:05,444 --> 00:08:07,029
Bailiff, you'll escort the jury

139
00:08:07,112 --> 00:08:09,156
to the jury room
for deliberation.

140
00:08:10,449 --> 00:08:12,367
Court is recessed
till the verdict's been reached.

141
00:08:14,036 --> 00:08:15,495
That homicide, Sharon,

142
00:08:15,579 --> 00:08:18,665
she's as full of holes
as a wheel of Swiss cheese.

143
00:08:18,749 --> 00:08:21,001
-Open and shut.
-Could be out of here by 4.30 pm.

144
00:08:21,084 --> 00:08:23,212
I thought a murder trial
would take weeks.

145
00:08:23,295 --> 00:08:24,796
As long as the county's paying,
let's order lunch.

146
00:08:24,880 --> 00:08:26,590
Won't have time to eat it.

147
00:08:26,673 --> 00:08:30,052
Mr. Bentley, please,
may I call you Thornton?

148
00:08:30,135 --> 00:08:31,553
You can call me Margo.

149
00:08:31,637 --> 00:08:34,431
-I'm a widow.
-Ally Collins, single sex.

150
00:08:34,514 --> 00:08:36,433
-Can we get some coffee?
-It's over here.

151
00:08:36,516 --> 00:08:41,063
Excuse me. Excuse me, everyone.
Please, we do have a foreperson.

152
00:08:41,146 --> 00:08:42,356
Oh, thank you, Jackie.

153
00:08:42,439 --> 00:08:44,900
I have to warn you
that I have never been

154
00:08:44,983 --> 00:08:47,903
a jury foreperson before.

155
00:08:47,986 --> 00:08:50,405
I'm afraid this case ain't gonna
let you be one for long,

156
00:08:50,489 --> 00:08:51,531
-Mrs. Fletcher.
-Well,

157
00:08:51,615 --> 00:08:52,908
however long it takes.

158
00:08:52,991 --> 00:08:57,037
And I hope that you will help me
to make the job as easy as possible.

159
00:08:57,120 --> 00:08:59,414
Madam foreman, if I may.

160
00:08:59,498 --> 00:09:01,792
I think that we are all pretty much
of the same mind.

161
00:09:01,875 --> 00:09:04,461
So the job really doesn't call
for very much more than our vote.

162
00:09:04,878 --> 00:09:07,756
Well, don't you think we should
examine the evidence first?

163
00:09:08,090 --> 00:09:10,008
The evidence says
he's innocent of homicide.

164
00:09:10,092 --> 00:09:12,052
He's guilty of one thing:
picking the wrong time

165
00:09:12,135 --> 00:09:14,096
at the wrong place to go to bed
with another man's wife.

166
00:09:14,179 --> 00:09:16,598
You ride right over that fact now.

167
00:09:16,682 --> 00:09:18,600
He was in bed
with another man's wife

168
00:09:18,684 --> 00:09:20,185
and he killed him
when he walked in on them.

169
00:09:20,269 --> 00:09:21,687
In self defense!

170
00:09:21,770 --> 00:09:24,523
Oh yes. About that...

171
00:09:24,606 --> 00:09:28,068
there's one or two points there
that I don't quite understand.

172
00:09:28,151 --> 00:09:30,070
-I'm not quite clear--
-Can I please make a point?

173
00:09:30,654 --> 00:09:32,823
This case is nothing
but a great big sales pitch

174
00:09:32,906 --> 00:09:35,617
by a politically ambitious
district attorney.

175
00:09:35,701 --> 00:09:37,536
As I tell them on my radio show,

176
00:09:37,619 --> 00:09:40,831
it's the product that counts,
not the package.

177
00:09:40,914 --> 00:09:43,250
Well, a product or a package,
I'm not buying either one.

178
00:09:43,333 --> 00:09:46,420
The point is, that this case
should never have come to trial.

179
00:09:46,503 --> 00:09:49,423
Then let's vote. At least we'll know
how close we are to a verdict.

180
00:09:49,506 --> 00:09:52,217
Yes, I think that might be
a very helpful idea.

181
00:09:52,301 --> 00:09:54,219
Frank, how should we go about...

182
00:09:54,303 --> 00:09:57,806
It's very simple. I think all we do
is write down our verdict,

183
00:09:57,889 --> 00:09:59,599
I'll collect 'em,
and you can count 'em.

184
00:09:59,683 --> 00:10:02,477
Very well. Shall we, uh...?

185
00:10:05,480 --> 00:10:07,524
Here we are.

186
00:10:07,607 --> 00:10:11,028
Nine to two for acquittal
and one undecided.

187
00:10:11,111 --> 00:10:13,155
It seems we're not too far
from an agreement.

188
00:10:14,031 --> 00:10:15,032
Why do I get the feeling

189
00:10:15,115 --> 00:10:16,700
that we're going to be here
for a while?

190
00:10:16,783 --> 00:10:18,952
Maybe it won't seem so long
once we get started.

191
00:10:19,036 --> 00:10:20,954
Started?
Start where?

192
00:10:21,038 --> 00:10:23,206
Well, we could begin
with Mark Reynolds's testimony.

193
00:10:23,290 --> 00:10:25,417
I'd say that's
a very good place to start.

194
00:10:25,500 --> 00:10:28,086
Oh, fine!
Which part of his testimony?

195
00:10:28,170 --> 00:10:31,131
Well, how about
where his attorney asked him--

196
00:10:31,673 --> 00:10:35,218
Mark, what did you feel
when Dr. Webster told you,

197
00:10:35,302 --> 00:10:38,972
if your wife lived,
she'd be paralyzed?

198
00:10:40,682 --> 00:10:43,852
I felt, uhm... guilty.

199
00:10:44,353 --> 00:10:49,191
And I felt... lost. Empty...

200
00:10:49,983 --> 00:10:53,612
What did you intend
when you ran out of the hospital?

201
00:10:54,196 --> 00:10:57,324
I don't know.

202
00:10:58,533 --> 00:10:59,910
I know I wanted to die.

203
00:11:01,078 --> 00:11:02,454
But you went to a bar.

204
00:11:04,039 --> 00:11:06,541
Well, I ended up in a bar.

205
00:11:06,625 --> 00:11:09,294
Will you tell the court
why you went there?

206
00:11:10,879 --> 00:11:14,341
To drink. To get drunk.

207
00:11:15,175 --> 00:11:18,678
And to drown out...

208
00:11:19,846 --> 00:11:21,181
reality.

209
00:11:21,264 --> 00:11:25,519
My golly, in my day,
I did a lot of that.

210
00:11:25,602 --> 00:11:27,145
But for different reasons.

211
00:11:27,229 --> 00:11:29,731
I don't think anybody
could call that unusual.

212
00:11:30,190 --> 00:11:32,734
Under those circumstances,
you're probably right.

213
00:11:32,818 --> 00:11:35,737
But remember,
the district attorney's question

214
00:11:35,821 --> 00:11:37,656
in cross-examination?

215
00:11:37,739 --> 00:11:39,491
Why that bar, Mr. Reynolds?

216
00:11:40,575 --> 00:11:41,910
Between the hospital
and the Last Resort,

217
00:11:41,993 --> 00:11:43,954
there are six places
where you could have

218
00:11:44,037 --> 00:11:46,581
drowned your guilt.
Why did you go to that one?

219
00:11:47,124 --> 00:11:49,668
-I-I don't know. I just--
-Was it because Becky Anderson

220
00:11:49,751 --> 00:11:51,253
was waiting there for you?

221
00:11:51,336 --> 00:11:52,462
-No.
-Waiting for you to play

222
00:11:52,546 --> 00:11:54,005
the little game of accidental meeting?

223
00:11:54,089 --> 00:11:55,006
-No.
-Knowing that you're

224
00:11:55,090 --> 00:11:57,259
leaving together would
lure her husband to her apartment

225
00:11:57,342 --> 00:11:58,760
so you could murder him.

226
00:11:58,844 --> 00:12:00,178
That's badgering, your honor.

227
00:12:00,262 --> 00:12:02,139
My client has answered
the question twice.

228
00:12:02,222 --> 00:12:03,098
No further questions
at this time.

229
00:12:04,766 --> 00:12:06,059
As far as I'm concerned,

230
00:12:06,143 --> 00:12:08,311
those questions
did not have to be asked.

231
00:12:08,395 --> 00:12:11,064
Except, that so happens
to be his case.

232
00:12:11,148 --> 00:12:12,607
Exactly, and it's no case.

233
00:12:12,691 --> 00:12:14,443
Do you mind if I say something?

234
00:12:15,068 --> 00:12:18,071
-Miss Conniver?
-It's just that--

235
00:12:18,155 --> 00:12:21,450
Well, when Mark Reynolds
was talking, I--

236
00:12:21,533 --> 00:12:24,035
I never got the feeling
he was trying to impress us.

237
00:12:24,578 --> 00:12:27,581
He was just telling us
the simple truth.

238
00:12:27,664 --> 00:12:30,542
Is this your first time
on jury duty, Ms. Conniver?

239
00:12:30,625 --> 00:12:33,587
Look, I served
on six juries, bud.

240
00:12:33,670 --> 00:12:35,714
This happens to be
my second murder trial.

241
00:12:35,797 --> 00:12:37,716
What about you?

242
00:12:37,799 --> 00:12:39,009
I agree with Ms. Conniver.

243
00:12:39,092 --> 00:12:41,470
If anything, I thought that
Mark Reynolds' testimony

244
00:12:41,553 --> 00:12:43,221
was very straight-forward.

245
00:12:43,305 --> 00:12:45,140
Because he had nothing to hide.

246
00:12:45,223 --> 00:12:48,185
He certainly didn't hedge around
about the way he met Becky Anderson.

247
00:12:48,810 --> 00:12:50,228
Will you tell the jury, Mark,

248
00:12:50,312 --> 00:12:52,647
how long
you were in the Last Resort?

249
00:12:53,773 --> 00:12:56,902
Uh, I don't honestly know.

250
00:12:56,985 --> 00:12:59,571
Uh, probably about two hours.

251
00:12:59,654 --> 00:13:01,531
And it was there that
you met Becky Anderson?

252
00:13:01,615 --> 00:13:03,825
-That's right.
-For the first time?

253
00:13:03,909 --> 00:13:04,784
Yes.

254
00:13:05,619 --> 00:13:07,996
Did you have
much to drink, Mark?

255
00:13:09,998 --> 00:13:11,333
I guess I did.

256
00:13:11,416 --> 00:13:13,585
You talked
for almost two hours.

257
00:13:13,668 --> 00:13:15,462
And then?

258
00:13:16,421 --> 00:13:20,342
Then, uh, she drove us
to her apartment.

259
00:13:20,425 --> 00:13:22,219
We talked for a while.

260
00:13:22,302 --> 00:13:24,638
She made some coffee.

261
00:13:24,721 --> 00:13:26,014
And then--

262
00:13:26,806 --> 00:13:28,975
Did you know
Becky Anderson was married?

263
00:13:29,059 --> 00:13:31,728
No. I've since found out

264
00:13:31,811 --> 00:13:33,939
that she was planning
to get divorced.

265
00:13:34,022 --> 00:13:36,066
In fact,
was separated from her husband

266
00:13:36,149 --> 00:13:37,108
for several months?

267
00:13:37,192 --> 00:13:38,860
Yes.

268
00:13:38,944 --> 00:13:40,111
Go on, please.

269
00:13:40,195 --> 00:13:41,696
What happened next?

270
00:13:41,780 --> 00:13:43,740
[inhales, exhales]

271
00:13:43,823 --> 00:13:45,450
Well, all of a sudden,

272
00:13:45,534 --> 00:13:48,119
there was a noise
in the apartment. Some shouting.

273
00:13:48,954 --> 00:13:50,914
It was Clifford Anderson.

274
00:13:51,957 --> 00:13:53,833
The next thing I knew was,
he was--

275
00:13:53,917 --> 00:13:55,877
he was in the bedroom.

276
00:13:55,961 --> 00:13:58,338
He had a gun.

277
00:13:58,421 --> 00:14:00,715
He-- he went after her.

278
00:14:00,799 --> 00:14:02,801
And then he came after me.

279
00:14:09,432 --> 00:14:11,017
The gun went off,

280
00:14:11,601 --> 00:14:12,811
and I found myself with a--

281
00:14:12,894 --> 00:14:15,188
with a fireplace poker
in my hand.

282
00:14:15,272 --> 00:14:17,857
And I hit him...
hard.

283
00:14:17,941 --> 00:14:20,819
What did you do
when you realized he was dead?

284
00:14:22,904 --> 00:14:25,323
Becky called the police.

285
00:14:25,407 --> 00:14:28,034
And, uh, I was
taken to the station.

286
00:14:28,118 --> 00:14:30,036
And you called a lawyer.

287
00:14:30,120 --> 00:14:31,496
You were allowed a call.

288
00:14:31,580 --> 00:14:35,458
No. I-I-I-- I called the hospital...

289
00:14:35,542 --> 00:14:37,836
to ask about my wife.

290
00:14:37,919 --> 00:14:41,464
And, uh,
they told me...

291
00:14:41,548 --> 00:14:45,635
that Stephanie had died
without regaining consciousness.

292
00:14:46,261 --> 00:14:48,346
I don't know
what more you need, Thornton.

293
00:14:48,430 --> 00:14:50,390
The husband attacked him!
He defended himself!

294
00:14:50,473 --> 00:14:52,809
-I don't believe a word of it.
-Well, I do.

295
00:14:52,892 --> 00:14:54,644
You people are crazy!
He's lying!

296
00:14:54,728 --> 00:14:56,938
What makes you
think so, Mr. Bentley?

297
00:14:57,022 --> 00:14:58,148
I know he is!
I know it here!

298
00:14:58,231 --> 00:15:00,191
That's a great way
to reach a verdict.

299
00:15:00,275 --> 00:15:02,819
Look, miss, I know
that man is guilty as sin,

300
00:15:02,902 --> 00:15:05,196
and there isn't anybody here
gonna change that.

301
00:15:06,072 --> 00:15:07,198
It don't take much to see

302
00:15:07,282 --> 00:15:08,992
who the bleeding hearts are
in this room,

303
00:15:09,075 --> 00:15:10,619
but I don't much care.

304
00:15:10,702 --> 00:15:11,995
We can sit here till
Christmastime

305
00:15:12,078 --> 00:15:13,163
if that's what you want.

306
00:15:13,246 --> 00:15:15,665
That man is guilty!

307
00:15:15,749 --> 00:15:17,417
[jurors arguing, indistinct]

308
00:15:17,500 --> 00:15:20,253
Gentlemen! Gentlemen!
Gentlemen! Gentlemen!

309
00:15:20,337 --> 00:15:22,797
Please.
Please.

310
00:15:22,881 --> 00:15:25,467
Mr. Callahan, Mr. Lord,
won't you please sit down?

311
00:15:25,550 --> 00:15:26,968
Well, what is the point, Mrs.
Fletcher?

312
00:15:27,052 --> 00:15:28,261
This jury has just been hung

313
00:15:28,345 --> 00:15:30,805
by this gentleman
with the open mind.

314
00:15:30,889 --> 00:15:32,515
More like an open cavity,
if you ask me.

315
00:15:32,599 --> 00:15:33,808
Oh, please!

316
00:15:33,892 --> 00:15:36,478
Mr. Bentley is entitled to hold
any opinion that he wishes.

317
00:15:36,561 --> 00:15:39,648
Now, maybe we should
dig deeper into the testimony.

318
00:15:39,731 --> 00:15:41,274
Oh, come on, Mrs. Fletcher.

319
00:15:41,358 --> 00:15:42,734
Now,
there was another witness

320
00:15:42,817 --> 00:15:44,319
who saw what happened
early that morning,

321
00:15:44,402 --> 00:15:45,737
and that was Becky Anderson.

322
00:15:45,820 --> 00:15:47,197
You say your husband

323
00:15:47,280 --> 00:15:49,324
had no right
to come to your house?

324
00:15:49,407 --> 00:15:52,827
No, he didn't.
We were separated.

325
00:15:52,911 --> 00:15:54,496
I had a restraining order.

326
00:15:54,579 --> 00:15:56,498
Your pending divorce,
what are the grounds?

327
00:15:56,581 --> 00:15:57,499
Objection.

328
00:15:57,582 --> 00:15:59,959
Question has no bearing
on the case at hand.

329
00:16:00,043 --> 00:16:02,253
Well, it does if it indicates
the character of the witness.

330
00:16:02,337 --> 00:16:04,756
Overruled.
The witness will answer.

331
00:16:04,839 --> 00:16:07,425
Irreconcilable differences.

332
00:16:07,509 --> 00:16:11,137
And your husband countersued,

333
00:16:11,221 --> 00:16:13,139
accusing you of infidelity.

334
00:16:13,223 --> 00:16:15,225
He had no grounds.

335
00:16:15,308 --> 00:16:18,937
Mrs. Anderson,

336
00:16:19,020 --> 00:16:21,731
could you give me a--
a rough estimate

337
00:16:21,815 --> 00:16:23,108
of the number of men
you've taken home

338
00:16:23,191 --> 00:16:24,359
from various bars around town?

339
00:16:24,442 --> 00:16:25,944
Your honor, I object!

340
00:16:26,027 --> 00:16:28,321
Mr. Casselli,
you know better than that.

341
00:16:28,405 --> 00:16:30,156
My apologies, your honor.

342
00:16:31,491 --> 00:16:33,284
Mrs. Anderson,

343
00:16:33,368 --> 00:16:36,079
how many times had
you slept with the defendant?

344
00:16:36,162 --> 00:16:37,580
Once.
I told you that.

345
00:16:37,664 --> 00:16:39,624
And did you know
Mark Reynolds before that night?

346
00:16:39,708 --> 00:16:40,875
No!

347
00:16:40,959 --> 00:16:42,419
You never saw him

348
00:16:42,502 --> 00:16:44,212
before the night
your husband was murdered?

349
00:16:44,295 --> 00:16:45,422
No.

350
00:16:45,922 --> 00:16:47,841
I, for one, really resented

351
00:16:47,924 --> 00:16:49,843
the district attorney's
line of questioning.

352
00:16:49,926 --> 00:16:52,512
She's as big a liar
as he is, Reynolds.

353
00:16:52,595 --> 00:16:54,222
And I'll tell you
something else, Callahan.

354
00:16:54,305 --> 00:16:56,099
Mr. Moneybags
is not what he seems.

355
00:16:56,182 --> 00:16:58,226
-Moneybags?
-Yeah.

356
00:16:58,309 --> 00:16:59,602
Rich and got it all!

357
00:16:59,686 --> 00:17:01,312
Used to havin'
everything his own way.

358
00:17:01,396 --> 00:17:02,397
Hey! Hey! Hey!
He isn't rich.

359
00:17:02,480 --> 00:17:05,400
-His wife had the money.
-He's got it now.

360
00:17:05,483 --> 00:17:08,111
Mr. Bentley,
Mark Reynolds is on trial,

361
00:17:08,194 --> 00:17:09,404
not his lifestyle.

362
00:17:09,487 --> 00:17:10,613
Oh, I take it, Mrs. Fletcher,

363
00:17:10,697 --> 00:17:12,240
you were one of the two
for conviction.

364
00:17:12,323 --> 00:17:13,491
If she wasn't,
you think we'd be

365
00:17:13,575 --> 00:17:16,244
sitting here
reexaminin' the evidence?

366
00:17:16,327 --> 00:17:19,330
Well, actually,
Mr. Corbin, I'm undecided.

367
00:17:19,414 --> 00:17:22,083
Oh!
You're the undecided one.

368
00:17:22,167 --> 00:17:23,918
What are you gonna try to do,
Mrs. Fletcher,

369
00:17:24,002 --> 00:17:26,254
turn this into one of
your convoluted whodunits?

370
00:17:26,963 --> 00:17:28,339
Look, I am afraid, Frank,

371
00:17:28,423 --> 00:17:31,676
that this case
is not as simple as it seems.

372
00:17:31,760 --> 00:17:33,553
Lady,
this is a very simple case

373
00:17:33,636 --> 00:17:34,888
of a one-night stand

374
00:17:34,971 --> 00:17:37,432
being marred by
a tragic coincidence.

375
00:17:37,515 --> 00:17:40,393
Interesting that you
should say "coincidence."

376
00:17:40,477 --> 00:17:42,854
And every whodunit's
got to have a few, right?

377
00:17:42,937 --> 00:17:46,524
And there's one that I have
a very hard time forgetting.

378
00:17:46,608 --> 00:17:49,778
A couple of things
have been puzzling me also.

379
00:17:49,861 --> 00:17:52,572
Oh, great!
Another country heard from.

380
00:17:52,655 --> 00:17:53,865
Well, excuse me,

381
00:17:53,948 --> 00:17:55,909
but I was bothered
by what Fenton Harris said.

382
00:17:55,992 --> 00:17:58,536
Yes, Jackie, so was I.

383
00:17:59,954 --> 00:18:02,499
My motel
is called the Bide-a-Wee.

384
00:18:02,582 --> 00:18:04,918
Always hated that name.
My wife picked it.

385
00:18:05,001 --> 00:18:06,461
Used to call her Lola.

386
00:18:06,544 --> 00:18:09,005
-She always got what she wanted.
[spectators laugh]

387
00:18:09,088 --> 00:18:11,299
Will you tell the court
where it's located?

388
00:18:11,382 --> 00:18:15,053
About 15 miles north of town,
out on route 37.

389
00:18:15,136 --> 00:18:18,765
Mr. Harris, do you recognize
anyone in the courtroom?

390
00:18:20,016 --> 00:18:21,935
In my business,
it's good practice

391
00:18:22,018 --> 00:18:25,480
never to recognize
the customers.

392
00:18:25,563 --> 00:18:27,649
[laughs] That's a little joke.

393
00:18:27,732 --> 00:18:29,400
Mr. Harris, please.

394
00:18:30,777 --> 00:18:34,113
You're askin'
if he ever came to my motel.

395
00:18:34,197 --> 00:18:37,158
He did.
Four, five, six times maybe.

396
00:18:37,242 --> 00:18:39,786
[spectators murmuring]

397
00:18:39,869 --> 00:18:41,913
Let the record show
that the witness

398
00:18:41,996 --> 00:18:44,749
identified Mark Reynolds,
the defendant.

399
00:18:46,251 --> 00:18:48,753
Will you tell the court
if you recognize anyone else?

400
00:18:49,754 --> 00:18:52,465
You mean, do I recognize her?

401
00:18:52,549 --> 00:18:54,092
Ms. Anderson there?

402
00:18:54,175 --> 00:18:55,552
Like I told you before,

403
00:18:55,635 --> 00:18:57,512
I think I seen her once
with Mr. Reynolds.

404
00:18:57,595 --> 00:18:59,556
[spectators murmuring]
-Didn't come in the office.

405
00:18:59,639 --> 00:19:01,182
Stayed outside in the car.

406
00:19:02,892 --> 00:19:05,061
[pounds gavel]
Order in the court.

407
00:19:06,813 --> 00:19:08,773
Order in the court!

408
00:19:09,649 --> 00:19:11,651
When was this, Mr. Harris,
approximately?

409
00:19:13,111 --> 00:19:17,031
About... three months ago.
Yeah.

410
00:19:17,115 --> 00:19:19,784
Making it six weeks
prior to the time

411
00:19:19,868 --> 00:19:21,494
that Mark Reynolds
and Becky Anderson

412
00:19:21,578 --> 00:19:24,122
claim they met
for the first time.

413
00:19:24,205 --> 00:19:25,707
I told you he was a liar!

414
00:19:25,790 --> 00:19:27,083
He said
he thought he saw her.

415
00:19:27,166 --> 00:19:28,501
He wasn't sure.

416
00:19:28,585 --> 00:19:30,044
How could he be sure?
He's half-blind.

417
00:19:30,128 --> 00:19:32,088
Mrs. Fletcher--

418
00:19:32,171 --> 00:19:35,091
Well, if there's a chance
that he recognized her,

419
00:19:35,174 --> 00:19:37,051
I think that
we seriously have to

420
00:19:37,135 --> 00:19:41,306
reexamine the notion that this
was merely a one-night stand.

421
00:19:41,389 --> 00:19:42,974
One moment, please!

422
00:19:43,057 --> 00:19:44,767
On cross-examination,

423
00:19:44,851 --> 00:19:46,769
Reynolds's lawyer got him
to admit he wasn't sure.

424
00:19:46,853 --> 00:19:47,770
Right.

425
00:19:47,854 --> 00:19:49,230
Yeah,
but suppose he was right

426
00:19:49,314 --> 00:19:50,481
and we choose to ignore it.

427
00:19:50,565 --> 00:19:51,858
Suppose this and suppose that.

428
00:19:51,941 --> 00:19:53,484
Now, you got to stop this,
Mrs. Fletcher.

429
00:19:53,568 --> 00:19:54,986
You can't turn this
into one of your

430
00:19:55,069 --> 00:19:56,446
make-believe murder mysteries.

431
00:19:56,529 --> 00:19:58,156
Yes.
All right, I agree.

432
00:19:58,239 --> 00:20:00,909
But even if the woman
in the car wasn't Becky,

433
00:20:00,992 --> 00:20:03,161
doesn't Mr. Harris's testimony
say something

434
00:20:03,244 --> 00:20:05,997
about Mark Reynolds's character
and his marriage?

435
00:20:06,372 --> 00:20:08,666
Yeah,
makes you wonder just how far

436
00:20:08,750 --> 00:20:09,959
you really can trust him.

437
00:20:10,043 --> 00:20:12,211
Mrs. MacKay, you likely
have nothing to do all day

438
00:20:12,295 --> 00:20:13,796
but sit home
and listen to soap operas.

439
00:20:13,880 --> 00:20:15,632
And just what is that
supposed to mean?

440
00:20:15,715 --> 00:20:17,759
It means that
I have a business to run.

441
00:20:17,842 --> 00:20:20,678
And I can't afford to waste
any more time away from my shop.

442
00:20:20,762 --> 00:20:22,764
Well, that's just too bad
about you, lady.

443
00:20:22,847 --> 00:20:25,308
There are a few more of us
with businesses to run.

444
00:20:25,391 --> 00:20:26,976
Short of turning this into
a hung jury,

445
00:20:27,060 --> 00:20:28,728
you're gonna have to
stick it out like we are.

446
00:20:28,811 --> 00:20:31,564
Look, I'm sure that none of us
want a hung jury, Mr. Bentley.

447
00:20:31,648 --> 00:20:33,483
Look, look.
About Reynolds' fooling around--

448
00:20:33,566 --> 00:20:34,609
I can understand that.

449
00:20:34,692 --> 00:20:35,985
My first wife had all the money.

450
00:20:36,069 --> 00:20:37,862
So I know what it feels like,
believe me.

451
00:20:37,946 --> 00:20:40,531
You just wanna prove something,
if only to yourself.

452
00:20:41,658 --> 00:20:42,867
Well, that's interesting.

453
00:20:42,951 --> 00:20:45,036
I-- I hadn't thought of it
that way.

454
00:20:45,119 --> 00:20:47,246
Well, he's got the money now--
enough to hire

455
00:20:47,330 --> 00:20:49,916
a fancy Manhattan lawyer
with his $600 suits.

456
00:20:49,999 --> 00:20:51,250
Oh, will you get off that.

457
00:20:51,334 --> 00:20:52,627
His lawyer is not on trial.

458
00:20:52,710 --> 00:20:54,462
Yeah.
Slick guy like that.

459
00:20:54,545 --> 00:20:56,339
Wonder why he didn't hire
somebody local.

460
00:20:56,422 --> 00:20:58,007
We keep getting
away from the issue.

461
00:20:58,091 --> 00:20:59,676
We sure do, folks.

462
00:20:59,759 --> 00:21:02,178
This is a man's life
we're deciding.

463
00:21:02,261 --> 00:21:03,638
Yes, that's right.

464
00:21:03,721 --> 00:21:04,722
And most of us here

465
00:21:04,806 --> 00:21:07,058
are of a mind
to let him keep it.

466
00:21:07,141 --> 00:21:08,851
It's Mrs. Fletcher
and her minions

467
00:21:08,935 --> 00:21:10,937
who are so anxious
to see him hang.

468
00:21:11,020 --> 00:21:12,647
Good heavens.
Is that what you think?

469
00:21:12,730 --> 00:21:17,026
Really, all I'm trying to do
is to examine both sides.

470
00:21:17,110 --> 00:21:19,195
And examine
and examine and examine.

471
00:21:19,278 --> 00:21:21,239
Well, I for one cannot
find any fault with that.

472
00:21:21,322 --> 00:21:22,865
Oh, right on cue, honey.

473
00:21:22,949 --> 00:21:24,450
We know
what Mr. Reynolds's lawyer

474
00:21:24,534 --> 00:21:27,412
wants us to believe.
Self-defense.

475
00:21:27,495 --> 00:21:29,372
But you'll remember
that the district attorney

476
00:21:29,455 --> 00:21:32,959
painted a very different picture
in his opening statement.

477
00:21:33,042 --> 00:21:36,421
The prosecution will prove
beyond a reasonable doubt

478
00:21:37,255 --> 00:21:41,134
that Mark Reynolds
and Becky Anderson were lovers.

479
00:21:41,884 --> 00:21:44,679
And that they conspired
to kill Clifford Anderson.

480
00:21:45,596 --> 00:21:46,597
If it was conspiracy,

481
00:21:46,681 --> 00:21:49,434
then why isn't
Becky Anderson on trial?

482
00:21:49,517 --> 00:21:50,727
Money, my friend.

483
00:21:50,810 --> 00:21:53,438
Her lawyer fixed it
so she'd get tried separately.

484
00:21:53,521 --> 00:21:54,897
Well, when we convict him,

485
00:21:54,981 --> 00:21:57,066
the next jury
will do the same to her.

486
00:21:57,150 --> 00:22:00,278
The district attorney
said reasonable doubt.

487
00:22:00,361 --> 00:22:01,362
Well, I've got it.

488
00:22:01,446 --> 00:22:02,947
That's why
I'm voting for acquittal.

489
00:22:03,031 --> 00:22:04,907
-So am I.
-And me.

490
00:22:04,991 --> 00:22:07,368
Yes, but what if
Fenton Harris did see Becky?

491
00:22:07,452 --> 00:22:09,996
What if Mark and Becky
weren't strangers?

492
00:22:10,079 --> 00:22:12,623
Gracious, I thought
we'd been all through that.

493
00:22:12,707 --> 00:22:14,584
-We did, miss Webster.
-Oh, for goodness' sake.

494
00:22:14,667 --> 00:22:17,211
Why can't you people
just listen for a minute?

495
00:22:17,295 --> 00:22:19,464
I mean, after all, this woman
has a brilliant criminal mind.

496
00:22:19,547 --> 00:22:22,800
[laughs]
-That's not what I meant.

497
00:22:22,884 --> 00:22:24,093
Well, you know,

498
00:22:24,177 --> 00:22:26,888
-maybe it's my "criminal mind"...
[chuckles]

499
00:22:26,971 --> 00:22:29,015
...that sees this as
a very complicated puzzle.

500
00:22:29,098 --> 00:22:32,101
And if so, please,
bear with me.

501
00:22:32,185 --> 00:22:35,980
But if Mr. Harris
saw them at his motel,

502
00:22:36,064 --> 00:22:40,151
what light does that shed
on the prosecution's case?

503
00:22:40,234 --> 00:22:42,737
And what about the bartender
at the Last Resort?

504
00:22:42,820 --> 00:22:44,947
And as I remember it,
he was very certain

505
00:22:45,031 --> 00:22:47,325
that he had never seen
Mark Reynolds before.

506
00:22:49,035 --> 00:22:50,161
How about Becky Anderson?

507
00:22:50,244 --> 00:22:51,913
Had you ever seen her before?

508
00:22:51,996 --> 00:22:53,206
Oh, sure.
She comes in a lot.

509
00:22:54,665 --> 00:22:56,918
-With her husband?
-Yeah.

510
00:22:57,001 --> 00:23:00,129
Before they broke up.
And afterwards, by herself.

511
00:23:01,756 --> 00:23:04,425
You'd call her a regular?

512
00:23:04,509 --> 00:23:06,469
Regular enough.

513
00:23:07,637 --> 00:23:09,055
Mr. Blevins,

514
00:23:10,098 --> 00:23:12,975
did Becky Anderson
ever pick up a man in the bar?

515
00:23:13,851 --> 00:23:15,144
Not that I ever saw.

516
00:23:15,228 --> 00:23:16,604
But she did
pick up Mark Reynolds?

517
00:23:17,939 --> 00:23:18,981
Well, I wouldn't exactly--

518
00:23:19,065 --> 00:23:21,025
They did meet there.

519
00:23:21,109 --> 00:23:23,402
And they left together.

520
00:23:24,278 --> 00:23:25,196
Is that correct?

521
00:23:25,279 --> 00:23:27,031
Yeah.

522
00:23:27,115 --> 00:23:28,783
On the surface,

523
00:23:28,866 --> 00:23:31,577
it appears that
two strangers meet in a bar

524
00:23:31,661 --> 00:23:33,329
and become fast friends.

525
00:23:33,412 --> 00:23:35,331
But if you believe Fenton Harris,

526
00:23:35,414 --> 00:23:36,999
the motel owner,
you have to believe

527
00:23:37,083 --> 00:23:39,127
that Mark and Becky
already knew one another.

528
00:23:39,210 --> 00:23:40,378
And if that's true,

529
00:23:40,461 --> 00:23:43,506
why this complicated charade
in the bar?

530
00:23:43,589 --> 00:23:45,466
They wouldn't
because they didn't.

531
00:23:45,550 --> 00:23:47,260
I know why!

532
00:23:47,343 --> 00:23:49,011
They wanted to be seen.

533
00:23:49,637 --> 00:23:53,057
Yes.
That's what I keep thinking.

534
00:23:53,141 --> 00:23:54,267
Oh, please!

535
00:23:54,350 --> 00:23:55,268
Remember when the barman

536
00:23:55,351 --> 00:23:57,812
said that Cliff Anderson
still came in.

537
00:23:57,895 --> 00:23:59,605
And even if he didn't
come in that night,

538
00:23:59,689 --> 00:24:02,233
they could expect some
other friends to come around.

539
00:24:02,316 --> 00:24:04,485
Somebody like Detweiler.

540
00:24:05,069 --> 00:24:07,738
Hey,
I wouldn't call Cliff a buddy,

541
00:24:07,822 --> 00:24:09,740
but bein' a married man myself,

542
00:24:09,824 --> 00:24:11,868
I'd want to know if
my old lady was cattin' around.

543
00:24:11,951 --> 00:24:12,952
So I figured he would too.

544
00:24:13,035 --> 00:24:16,581
So if the district attorney's
theory is correct,

545
00:24:16,664 --> 00:24:19,584
that phone call
triggered their plan

546
00:24:19,667 --> 00:24:21,502
to kill Becky's husband.

547
00:24:21,586 --> 00:24:25,339
Well, after that creep called,
Cliff was off like a shot.

548
00:24:26,215 --> 00:24:28,342
Had you
known the deceased long?

549
00:24:28,426 --> 00:24:31,387
Oh, yeah. We fished together,
oh, five or six years.

550
00:24:31,470 --> 00:24:33,389
He was livin' with me
for eight months.

551
00:24:33,472 --> 00:24:35,474
Would you say he had a temper?

552
00:24:35,558 --> 00:24:37,018
Temper?
[laughs]

553
00:24:37,101 --> 00:24:38,769
Does week-old fish bait stink?

554
00:24:38,853 --> 00:24:41,230
[spectators laughs]

555
00:24:42,899 --> 00:24:46,819
Well, the last thing
he did say was that...

556
00:24:46,903 --> 00:24:48,196
he was gonna kill her.

557
00:24:48,321 --> 00:24:49,155
[spectators murmuring]

558
00:24:49,238 --> 00:24:52,158
One final question:

559
00:24:52,241 --> 00:24:55,661
when Clifford Anderson
left your apartment,

560
00:24:55,745 --> 00:24:56,913
was he armed?

561
00:24:56,996 --> 00:24:58,539
Armed?
Are you kiddin'?

562
00:24:58,623 --> 00:25:01,500
Answer the question,
Mr. Patecki.

563
00:25:02,752 --> 00:25:04,295
No.

564
00:25:04,378 --> 00:25:07,215
He was not armed.

565
00:25:07,298 --> 00:25:08,216
Okay?

566
00:25:08,299 --> 00:25:09,133
Puzzle piece number one:

567
00:25:09,217 --> 00:25:11,219
where did Cliff Anderson
get the gun?

568
00:25:11,302 --> 00:25:13,095
Now, that's
an important question

569
00:25:13,179 --> 00:25:15,514
because a great deal
of the prosecution's case

570
00:25:15,598 --> 00:25:17,516
relies on the answer.

571
00:25:18,768 --> 00:25:20,645
I think
the general assumption was

572
00:25:20,728 --> 00:25:23,147
that he had picked it up
on his way to his wife's house.

573
00:25:23,231 --> 00:25:24,941
It was midnight
when he got the call.

574
00:25:25,024 --> 00:25:26,734
Where would he have gotten it?

575
00:25:26,817 --> 00:25:28,653
Remember, the ballistics expert

576
00:25:28,736 --> 00:25:31,280
said the gun
had no registration.

577
00:25:31,364 --> 00:25:32,990
A single shot was fired.

578
00:25:33,074 --> 00:25:36,285
And he said that
he had made a nitrate test

579
00:25:36,369 --> 00:25:38,287
on the hands of both
Mark Reynolds

580
00:25:38,371 --> 00:25:39,622
and Cliff Anderson.

581
00:25:39,705 --> 00:25:42,083
There were powder traces
on the hands of both,

582
00:25:42,166 --> 00:25:45,002
indicating that both held
the gun when it discharged.

583
00:25:45,086 --> 00:25:48,422
A matching slug was removed
from the living room wall.

584
00:25:48,506 --> 00:25:50,758
The only fingerprints
on that gun

585
00:25:50,841 --> 00:25:53,844
were those of Cliff Anderson
and Mark Reynolds.

586
00:25:53,928 --> 00:25:56,639
Proving a struggle.
Proving self-defense.

587
00:25:57,473 --> 00:25:58,724
-Proving that...
-Oh, come on!

588
00:25:58,808 --> 00:25:59,934
This whole thing
was planned

589
00:26:00,017 --> 00:26:01,686
to lure this poor man
to his death.

590
00:26:01,769 --> 00:26:04,730
And proving what I said
about Reynolds all along.

591
00:26:04,814 --> 00:26:06,732
You people must be
from some other planet.

592
00:26:06,816 --> 00:26:08,150
Will you listen to yourselves?

593
00:26:08,234 --> 00:26:09,777
A guy has a car accident.

594
00:26:09,860 --> 00:26:11,612
His wife is fatally injured,

595
00:26:11,696 --> 00:26:13,906
so he leaves her in a hospital
to go meet a dame

596
00:26:13,990 --> 00:26:15,574
because he and this dame
have some idea

597
00:26:15,658 --> 00:26:16,784
about killing her husband

598
00:26:16,867 --> 00:26:18,577
by maybe luring him
to her house?

599
00:26:18,661 --> 00:26:19,954
I mean, please!

600
00:26:20,037 --> 00:26:21,205
You got to have
rocks in your heads!

601
00:26:21,289 --> 00:26:22,540
What'd you say to me, buddy?

602
00:26:22,623 --> 00:26:24,041
You're ready
to stay here all year?

603
00:26:24,125 --> 00:26:26,002
Well, so am I, pal!

604
00:26:26,085 --> 00:26:27,420
And as for you, Mrs. Fletcher,

605
00:26:27,503 --> 00:26:29,422
you've let this whole thing
get out of hand.

606
00:26:29,505 --> 00:26:31,632
I think it's about time
for you to step aside

607
00:26:31,716 --> 00:26:33,634
and let somebody else
run these proceedings,

608
00:26:33,718 --> 00:26:36,971
somebody who has
a vague idea what they're doing.

609
00:26:39,640 --> 00:26:41,225
Oh, sit down.
You talk too much.

610
00:26:41,309 --> 00:26:44,270
Mrs. Fletcher's doing quite
nicely, thank you.

611
00:26:44,353 --> 00:26:46,731
I certainly
don't want the job.

612
00:26:46,814 --> 00:26:48,441
Mr. Lord,
I'm perfectly willing

613
00:26:48,524 --> 00:26:49,483
to step aside
if that's what--

614
00:26:49,567 --> 00:26:51,068
That won't be necessary,
Mrs. Fletcher.

615
00:26:51,152 --> 00:26:52,361
-Whoa, whoa, whoa.
-Frank, sit down.

616
00:26:52,445 --> 00:26:55,781
Hey! It's perfectly okay.
I got lots of time.

617
00:26:55,865 --> 00:26:58,075
Well,

618
00:26:58,159 --> 00:27:01,287
let's go back
to another part of the puzzle

619
00:27:01,370 --> 00:27:03,205
that doesn't quite fit--

620
00:27:03,289 --> 00:27:05,499
Becky Anderson's neighbor.

621
00:27:05,583 --> 00:27:08,085
Oh, yeah!
The wimp who came home...

622
00:27:08,169 --> 00:27:10,838
to find the husband's car
blocking the driveway.

623
00:27:11,714 --> 00:27:14,133
I had to leave my car
on the street.

624
00:27:14,216 --> 00:27:16,093
Did you go
say anything to him?

625
00:27:16,844 --> 00:27:20,264
With a temper like he had?
Mm-mm.

626
00:27:20,348 --> 00:27:22,558
Listen, if I was
Mr. Reynolds over there,

627
00:27:22,641 --> 00:27:24,185
and I saw Cliff Anderson

628
00:27:24,268 --> 00:27:25,978
come bustin'
through the door at me,

629
00:27:26,062 --> 00:27:27,646
I'd have grabbed for that poker.

630
00:27:27,730 --> 00:27:30,983
Better an ax or a gun,
if one was handy.

631
00:27:31,067 --> 00:27:31,901
[spectators murmuring]

632
00:27:34,695 --> 00:27:36,822
I'm here to tell ya
it's a good thing

633
00:27:36,906 --> 00:27:39,158
that young fella
used that poker.

634
00:27:39,241 --> 00:27:41,327
If he hadn't,
a couple of hours later,

635
00:27:41,410 --> 00:27:43,120
when I was
lookin' through the window,

636
00:27:43,204 --> 00:27:45,081
it would've been his body

637
00:27:45,164 --> 00:27:47,625
I'd have seen the ambulance
takin' away,

638
00:27:47,708 --> 00:27:48,626
not Cliff Anderson's.

639
00:27:49,335 --> 00:27:51,420
It still doesn't prove
conspiracy.

640
00:27:52,004 --> 00:27:53,923
It does prove
that if Mark and Becky

641
00:27:54,006 --> 00:27:55,758
were looking
for a volatile response,

642
00:27:55,841 --> 00:27:58,844
all they had to do was
wait for Clifford Anderson...

643
00:27:58,928 --> 00:28:01,389
...to show up.

644
00:28:01,472 --> 00:28:04,767
And show up he did.

645
00:28:07,019 --> 00:28:09,647
But they were not in bed.

646
00:28:10,815 --> 00:28:14,068
They had not been making love.

647
00:28:16,821 --> 00:28:18,948
They had been planning
his murder.

648
00:28:21,534 --> 00:28:24,328
They heard him
drive up in front.

649
00:28:24,412 --> 00:28:26,163
They heard him
barge into the house.

650
00:28:26,247 --> 00:28:28,499
And when he stormed
towards the bedroom,

651
00:28:30,000 --> 00:28:32,420
they were waiting.

652
00:28:32,503 --> 00:28:34,296
He didn't have a gun.

653
00:28:34,380 --> 00:28:37,133
Mark Reynolds had the gun.

654
00:28:39,343 --> 00:28:40,678
An unregistered gun.

655
00:28:40,761 --> 00:28:42,721
He needed it...

656
00:28:42,805 --> 00:28:45,391
as evidence for his
self-defense.

657
00:28:48,018 --> 00:28:50,729
And when the murder was done,

658
00:28:50,813 --> 00:28:54,567
when the stage was set,

659
00:28:56,026 --> 00:28:58,070
then they called the police.

660
00:29:00,948 --> 00:29:04,869
Speculation?
No.

661
00:29:04,952 --> 00:29:05,870
Ladies and gentlemen,

662
00:29:05,953 --> 00:29:08,539
it is fact.

663
00:29:12,835 --> 00:29:16,213
I look at these
two people, I see...

664
00:29:16,297 --> 00:29:19,925
pleasant,
all-American attractiveness.

665
00:29:20,968 --> 00:29:23,721
I'd like to believe
the story they told,

666
00:29:26,056 --> 00:29:27,892
but I can't.

667
00:29:30,478 --> 00:29:33,063
Perhaps if they'd agreed
to a lie detector examination--

668
00:29:33,147 --> 00:29:34,523
Your honor, objection!

669
00:29:34,607 --> 00:29:36,150
Sustained.

670
00:29:36,233 --> 00:29:38,402
Mr. Casselli,
you know better than that.

671
00:29:38,486 --> 00:29:40,404
Yes.
I do, your honor,

672
00:29:40,488 --> 00:29:42,490
and I beg
the court's forgiveness.

673
00:29:43,115 --> 00:29:44,533
That was a pretty cheap trick.

674
00:29:44,617 --> 00:29:47,578
Even I know you can't talk about
a lie detector in a courtroom.

675
00:29:47,661 --> 00:29:49,038
But he did.
And we heard him.

676
00:29:49,121 --> 00:29:51,832
If they had nothing to hide,
why didn't they take the test?

677
00:29:51,916 --> 00:29:54,668
You know, for once, Bentley,
I think you do have a point.

678
00:29:54,752 --> 00:29:57,671
Mrs. Fletcher, maybe
you've been right all along.

679
00:29:57,755 --> 00:29:59,882
Well, I haven't been saying
that I'm right, Mr. Callahan.

680
00:29:59,965 --> 00:30:01,759
I'm just trying to find
the proper pieces

681
00:30:01,842 --> 00:30:03,177
to fit into the proper places.

682
00:30:03,260 --> 00:30:06,055
Perhaps we were a little hasty
presuming Reynolds was innocent.

683
00:30:06,138 --> 00:30:08,224
Maybe Cliff Anderson
didn't have the gun.

684
00:30:08,307 --> 00:30:09,558
Oh, no.

685
00:30:09,642 --> 00:30:11,477
If there's one thing
I am ready to accept,

686
00:30:11,560 --> 00:30:14,230
it's that he brought that gun
into the house with him.

687
00:30:14,313 --> 00:30:15,523
If he had the gun
with him--

688
00:30:15,606 --> 00:30:16,607
Now, wait a minute.

689
00:30:16,690 --> 00:30:18,317
You talk half this room
out of believing

690
00:30:18,400 --> 00:30:20,110
it was self-defense,
and then you tell us--

691
00:30:20,194 --> 00:30:22,363
I'm not telling you anything,
miss Collins.

692
00:30:22,446 --> 00:30:24,573
But I would like you to remember

693
00:30:24,657 --> 00:30:26,784
the testimony
of that traffic officer.

694
00:30:26,867 --> 00:30:29,537
Oh, sure.
I remember him.

695
00:30:29,620 --> 00:30:33,666
He arrested Anderson
a year ago on drunken driving.

696
00:30:33,749 --> 00:30:35,459
He found a gun
in the glove compartment!

697
00:30:35,543 --> 00:30:38,504
And I seem to remember
he confiscated it.

698
00:30:38,587 --> 00:30:40,256
Yes,
but doesn't it seem logical

699
00:30:40,339 --> 00:30:43,092
that a man like that
might buy another one?

700
00:30:43,175 --> 00:30:44,885
Mrs. Fletcher,
you're-- you're bringing us

701
00:30:44,969 --> 00:30:46,971
right back
where we started from.

702
00:30:47,054 --> 00:30:48,264
Not really.

703
00:30:48,764 --> 00:30:49,807
What do you mean not really?

704
00:30:50,140 --> 00:30:51,559
If Anderson brought the gun,

705
00:30:51,642 --> 00:30:53,435
then Reynolds killing him
was self-defense,

706
00:30:53,519 --> 00:30:54,895
which it was not.

707
00:30:54,979 --> 00:30:58,107
I'm sorry, Mr. Bentley,
but it may have been.

708
00:30:58,190 --> 00:30:59,233
Oh, really, Mrs. Fletcher.

709
00:30:59,316 --> 00:31:00,401
That's what
we've been contending

710
00:31:00,484 --> 00:31:01,527
since we walked in here.

711
00:31:01,610 --> 00:31:03,612
What a joyous waste of time
this has been.

712
00:31:03,696 --> 00:31:05,030
Really, miss Collins!

713
00:31:05,114 --> 00:31:07,825
If you didn't want to serve,
what are you doing here?

714
00:31:07,908 --> 00:31:08,993
I couldn't dream up

715
00:31:09,076 --> 00:31:10,411
another excuse they'd believe,
okay?

716
00:31:10,494 --> 00:31:12,580
Oh, please!

717
00:31:12,663 --> 00:31:14,290
Look, I posed the question
about the gun

718
00:31:14,373 --> 00:31:17,293
because we have all been
overlooking something,

719
00:31:17,376 --> 00:31:19,169
and me included, I'm afraid.

720
00:31:19,253 --> 00:31:21,297
Well, hallelujah.

721
00:31:21,380 --> 00:31:23,882
It bears
on the struggle for the gun.

722
00:31:23,966 --> 00:31:25,384
And what would that be?

723
00:31:25,467 --> 00:31:27,344
The fact that Mark Reynolds

724
00:31:27,428 --> 00:31:30,973
had injured his shoulder
in the automobile accident.

725
00:31:31,056 --> 00:31:32,850
Remember the testimony
of the paramedics

726
00:31:32,933 --> 00:31:34,768
who took Mark and his wife
to the hospital?

727
00:31:35,561 --> 00:31:37,104
He was in a lot of pain.

728
00:31:37,730 --> 00:31:39,023
He'd broken his left collarbone,

729
00:31:39,106 --> 00:31:40,608
but he didn't want us
to touch him.

730
00:31:40,691 --> 00:31:41,650
Why was that?

731
00:31:41,734 --> 00:31:43,652
He didn't want us
to take the time.

732
00:31:43,736 --> 00:31:45,654
He wanted us
to get his wife to the hospital

733
00:31:45,738 --> 00:31:46,739
as fast as we could.

734
00:31:48,616 --> 00:31:49,658
Somebody told me later

735
00:31:49,742 --> 00:31:51,702
they'd been married
less than a year.

736
00:31:52,620 --> 00:31:54,121
He was really broken up.

737
00:31:55,080 --> 00:31:58,208
His wife had come to
for a moment.

738
00:31:58,292 --> 00:32:00,002
"Why?" she says.

739
00:32:00,085 --> 00:32:01,503
He'd swerved to keep
from hitting

740
00:32:01,587 --> 00:32:03,380
some kid on a bike

741
00:32:03,464 --> 00:32:05,799
and has to watch her
lie there dying.

742
00:32:06,925 --> 00:32:09,595
The last thing he was
thinking about was himself.

743
00:32:09,678 --> 00:32:12,473
When Dr. Webster was
called to the stand to testify,

744
00:32:12,556 --> 00:32:13,515
he said the same thing.

745
00:32:13,724 --> 00:32:16,518
Mrs. Fletcher, will you
please get to the point?

746
00:32:16,602 --> 00:32:20,105
Well, my point is that neither
the paramedic nor Dr. Webster

747
00:32:20,189 --> 00:32:22,232
treated Mark Reynolds's
shoulder.

748
00:32:23,067 --> 00:32:24,610
Are you implying
he wasn't hurt?

749
00:32:24,693 --> 00:32:26,487
Oh, no.
No, not at all.

750
00:32:26,570 --> 00:32:28,906
Mr. Reynolds
was obviously in pain.

751
00:32:28,989 --> 00:32:31,116
But his only concern
was for his wife.

752
00:32:31,742 --> 00:32:33,786
The idea
that she might never walk

753
00:32:33,869 --> 00:32:35,496
sent him into a frenzy.

754
00:32:35,579 --> 00:32:37,831
I wish he'd stayed with her.

755
00:32:37,915 --> 00:32:40,459
But a little after 1:00,
she suddenly went sour.

756
00:32:40,542 --> 00:32:42,461
The heart monitor
alerted the nurses,

757
00:32:42,544 --> 00:32:44,254
but by the time
they could get to her room,

758
00:32:44,338 --> 00:32:45,673
she was gone.

759
00:32:45,756 --> 00:32:47,841
If Mr. Reynolds
had been with her,

760
00:32:47,925 --> 00:32:50,678
well, perhaps they might have
reached her faster.

761
00:32:51,887 --> 00:32:53,972
But who knows?

762
00:32:54,556 --> 00:32:56,308
Okay,
so would you please tell us

763
00:32:56,392 --> 00:32:57,976
what does the broken collarbone

764
00:32:58,060 --> 00:33:00,938
have to do with
whether or not he had the gun?

765
00:33:01,021 --> 00:33:03,607
Would you stand up, Mr. Lord?

766
00:33:03,691 --> 00:33:06,527
May I borrow your cane
just for a moment, please?

767
00:33:10,280 --> 00:33:11,990
Mr. Lord.

768
00:33:12,449 --> 00:33:14,368
Good.
You're right-handed too.

769
00:33:14,451 --> 00:33:15,786
What do you mean "too"?

770
00:33:15,869 --> 00:33:16,912
Well, Mark Reynolds's

771
00:33:16,995 --> 00:33:19,164
right-hand fingerprints
were on the poker.

772
00:33:19,915 --> 00:33:23,877
His injury made his left arm
practically useless.

773
00:33:23,961 --> 00:33:25,462
It would have been
almost impossible

774
00:33:25,546 --> 00:33:27,005
for him to aim the gun,

775
00:33:27,089 --> 00:33:29,007
let alone struggle over it
with Clifford Anderson.

776
00:33:29,091 --> 00:33:30,509
Well, maybe Becky had the gun.

777
00:33:30,592 --> 00:33:33,011
Yes, but the traces of
gunpowder were on his left hand.

778
00:33:33,095 --> 00:33:34,263
His and Cliff's.

779
00:33:34,346 --> 00:33:35,764
Good point.

780
00:33:35,848 --> 00:33:38,016
But if he couldn't hold a gun,

781
00:33:38,100 --> 00:33:39,476
much less struggle for one,

782
00:33:39,560 --> 00:33:41,478
then how did
the powder traces get there?

783
00:33:41,562 --> 00:33:44,189
Well, that's a question
I can't answer.

784
00:33:44,273 --> 00:33:47,484
Now, there are a couple
of other things that bother me.

785
00:33:47,568 --> 00:33:49,486
Well,
with what you just came up with,

786
00:33:49,570 --> 00:33:50,946
I'm willing to listen.

787
00:33:51,029 --> 00:33:52,448
You may be willing
to listen to it.

788
00:33:52,531 --> 00:33:53,490
I think I've had it.

789
00:33:53,574 --> 00:33:55,325
Well, why don't you just
keep an open mind?

790
00:33:55,409 --> 00:33:56,785
Listen, my friend.

791
00:33:56,869 --> 00:33:59,496
There's only so much testimony,
and we've gone over it all.

792
00:33:59,580 --> 00:34:01,540
No,
the stuff about the left arm,

793
00:34:01,623 --> 00:34:03,917
the powder traces--

794
00:34:04,001 --> 00:34:05,586
That makes it all
a different story for me.

795
00:34:05,669 --> 00:34:07,588
I say we stick to
our original verdict.

796
00:34:07,671 --> 00:34:09,173
I'm voting for self-defense.

797
00:34:09,256 --> 00:34:10,924
Sorry.
I can't go along anymore.

798
00:34:11,008 --> 00:34:13,469
Mrs. Fletcher's
stopped me cold on self-defense.

799
00:34:14,636 --> 00:34:16,722
But still, murder?

800
00:34:16,805 --> 00:34:19,558
Broken collarbones,
powder traces, whatever.

801
00:34:19,641 --> 00:34:21,727
Anderson is dead.
Reynolds killed him.

802
00:34:22,060 --> 00:34:23,020
I'm still calling it that.

803
00:34:23,103 --> 00:34:25,355
Hey, I've heard nothin'
that changes my mind.

804
00:34:25,439 --> 00:34:26,607
Maybe that's because
you people

805
00:34:26,690 --> 00:34:28,650
haven't been listening
very hard.

806
00:34:29,443 --> 00:34:31,403
Mrs. Fletcher has made
a lot of sense so far.

807
00:34:31,487 --> 00:34:34,364
Why can't we just keep
talking and listening, huh?

808
00:34:34,448 --> 00:34:37,284
I mean, we're 12 reasonably
intelligent people here.

809
00:34:37,367 --> 00:34:39,244
We ought to be able
to sort this thing out.

810
00:34:39,328 --> 00:34:41,747
Damn it, that's what
we're here for, isn't it?

811
00:34:44,958 --> 00:34:47,878
Well, she is right.
Why don't we just keep at it?

812
00:34:48,796 --> 00:34:51,799
Okay, Mrs. Fletcher,
you've got the floor.

813
00:34:52,716 --> 00:34:53,842
Oh, dear.

814
00:34:53,926 --> 00:34:56,595
I wish I could be
a little bit more sure

815
00:34:56,678 --> 00:34:58,847
about what I'm doing with it.

816
00:34:58,931 --> 00:35:02,726
Now-- Now, look,
I have three major problems,

817
00:35:02,810 --> 00:35:05,979
things that make no sense
the way they were presented.

818
00:35:06,063 --> 00:35:08,357
For one thing,
I believe Mr. Harris.

819
00:35:08,440 --> 00:35:11,235
-The motel owner?
-Yes.

820
00:35:11,318 --> 00:35:14,404
I really do think that
Mark and Becky knew each other

821
00:35:14,488 --> 00:35:16,824
before the night
her husband was killed.

822
00:35:16,907 --> 00:35:18,951
Now we're getting somewhere.

823
00:35:19,034 --> 00:35:20,160
But, Mr. Lord,

824
00:35:20,244 --> 00:35:21,745
you also made
a very persuasive argument.

825
00:35:21,829 --> 00:35:24,832
I mean, it seems ludicrous
that these two people,

826
00:35:24,915 --> 00:35:27,584
with Mark's wife
lying critically ill

827
00:35:27,668 --> 00:35:29,044
in a hospital bed,

828
00:35:29,127 --> 00:35:30,254
would choose this night

829
00:35:30,337 --> 00:35:32,798
to lure Becky's husband
to his death.

830
00:35:32,881 --> 00:35:34,800
Well, thank you,
Mrs. Fletcher.

831
00:35:34,883 --> 00:35:36,260
No, no, no.

832
00:35:36,343 --> 00:35:38,637
If it wasn't premeditated,
then it had to be self-defense.

833
00:35:38,720 --> 00:35:39,805
There's nothing else.

834
00:35:40,347 --> 00:35:42,641
But there is something else,
miss Collins.

835
00:35:42,724 --> 00:35:47,396
A third possibility that
none of us have yet considered.

836
00:35:48,605 --> 00:35:49,815
[all arguing]

837
00:35:49,898 --> 00:35:52,442
Mrs. Fletcher,
what other possibility?

838
00:35:52,526 --> 00:35:53,527
What are you talking about?

839
00:35:53,819 --> 00:35:55,612
I'm afraid
this is all beyond me.

840
00:35:55,696 --> 00:35:57,030
Mrs. Fletcher,
if this is another one

841
00:35:57,114 --> 00:35:58,615
of your trips
to fantasyland--

842
00:35:58,699 --> 00:36:01,201
Frank, will you just sit there
and shut up and listen?

843
00:36:01,285 --> 00:36:03,370
Let's hear it, Mrs. Fletcher.

844
00:36:03,453 --> 00:36:05,122
Well, what we have to do

845
00:36:05,205 --> 00:36:08,166
is to take a look
at two particular statements,

846
00:36:08,250 --> 00:36:09,793
contradictory statements,

847
00:36:09,877 --> 00:36:12,129
starting with Mark Reynolds's
description

848
00:36:12,212 --> 00:36:14,381
of what happened
when Becky's husband

849
00:36:14,464 --> 00:36:16,091
burst through that bedroom door.

850
00:36:16,174 --> 00:36:17,634
We've gone over that.

851
00:36:18,302 --> 00:36:20,095
And I hope for the last time.

852
00:36:20,888 --> 00:36:23,932
Now, he said that
there were words exchanged,

853
00:36:24,016 --> 00:36:26,602
and suddenly they were
struggling with a gun.

854
00:36:26,685 --> 00:36:29,187
Mark picked up the poker.
The gun went off.

855
00:36:29,271 --> 00:36:31,815
And Mark struck
Anderson with the poker.

856
00:36:32,524 --> 00:36:33,692
Then the police were called.

857
00:36:34,234 --> 00:36:35,569
Now, all that
couldn't have taken

858
00:36:35,652 --> 00:36:37,571
more than five--
well, ten minutes at the most.

859
00:36:37,654 --> 00:36:39,281
No argument.
Go on.

860
00:36:39,364 --> 00:36:41,617
Then what about Arthur Jasper?

861
00:36:41,700 --> 00:36:43,452
-The next-door neighbor.
-Exactly.

862
00:36:43,535 --> 00:36:45,829
The next-door neighbor
whose driveway was blocked.

863
00:36:45,913 --> 00:36:47,247
Now how did he put it?

864
00:36:47,331 --> 00:36:50,208
"If Mark Reynolds
hadn't hit Cliff with the poker,

865
00:36:50,292 --> 00:36:52,377
a couple of hours later
when I looked out the window,

866
00:36:52,461 --> 00:36:53,545
it would have been his body

867
00:36:53,629 --> 00:36:55,130
being taken out
in that ambulance

868
00:36:55,213 --> 00:36:56,924
instead of Cliff Anderson's."

869
00:36:57,007 --> 00:36:59,217
-He did say that!
-Mm-hmm.

870
00:36:59,301 --> 00:37:01,219
"A couple of hours later."

871
00:37:01,303 --> 00:37:02,804
If Mark Reynolds
had been telling the truth,

872
00:37:02,888 --> 00:37:04,848
the police and the ambulance
would have been there--

873
00:37:04,932 --> 00:37:06,141
-Almost immediately.
-Yes.

874
00:37:06,224 --> 00:37:08,226
Then they lied.
Why?

875
00:37:08,310 --> 00:37:09,353
And what was Cliff Anderson

876
00:37:09,436 --> 00:37:10,979
doing in her apartment
all that time?

877
00:37:11,063 --> 00:37:12,814
And the way Reynolds told it,

878
00:37:12,898 --> 00:37:13,982
they called the police

879
00:37:14,066 --> 00:37:15,859
less than five minutes
after he got there.

880
00:37:15,943 --> 00:37:17,444
Obviously, they didn't.

881
00:37:17,527 --> 00:37:19,655
You were right, Mr. Narramore.
They lied.

882
00:37:20,155 --> 00:37:21,406
Leaving us, I'm afraid,

883
00:37:21,490 --> 00:37:24,159
with only one
inescapable conclusion.

884
00:37:24,993 --> 00:37:28,163
And only one possible verdict.

885
00:37:29,539 --> 00:37:30,707
[murmuring,
gavel pounding]

886
00:37:30,791 --> 00:37:33,502
The defendant will rise.

887
00:37:38,423 --> 00:37:39,883
Ladies and gentlemen
of the jury,

888
00:37:39,967 --> 00:37:41,385
have you reached a verdict?

889
00:37:42,844 --> 00:37:44,304
We have, your honor.

890
00:37:44,388 --> 00:37:45,347
How do you find?

891
00:37:45,430 --> 00:37:47,849
We find the defendant
not guilty.

892
00:37:47,933 --> 00:37:50,852
[spectators murmuring]

893
00:37:57,150 --> 00:38:00,028
The defendant is released.

894
00:38:00,112 --> 00:38:01,655
Ladies and gentlemen
of the jury,

895
00:38:01,738 --> 00:38:03,073
thank you for your efforts.

896
00:38:04,116 --> 00:38:05,117
Court is adjourned.

897
00:38:05,200 --> 00:38:06,451
[gavel bangs]

898
00:38:06,535 --> 00:38:09,538
[murmuring]

899
00:38:13,083 --> 00:38:14,876
-Mr. Casselli.
-Mrs. Fletcher.

900
00:38:14,960 --> 00:38:17,004
I thought I had
a pretty good case.

901
00:38:17,087 --> 00:38:18,380
I guess
I can save myself the effort

902
00:38:18,463 --> 00:38:19,673
of going after Mrs. Anderson.

903
00:38:19,756 --> 00:38:21,967
Oh, my, no.

904
00:38:22,384 --> 00:38:23,844
By all means,
I think you should,

905
00:38:23,927 --> 00:38:25,554
now more than ever.

906
00:38:26,263 --> 00:38:29,391
Could we meet in your office
in, say, 30 minutes?

907
00:38:29,850 --> 00:38:31,059
Sure, I suppose so, but--

908
00:38:31,143 --> 00:38:33,437
You might also ask
Becky Anderson

909
00:38:33,520 --> 00:38:34,896
to be there with her attorney.

910
00:38:35,397 --> 00:38:38,775
Look, before I put myself
in an awkward position,

911
00:38:38,859 --> 00:38:40,152
do you mind if I ask why?

912
00:38:40,652 --> 00:38:41,820
Oh, not at all.

913
00:38:41,903 --> 00:38:43,739
The last thing in the world
I want to do

914
00:38:43,822 --> 00:38:46,116
is to put you
in an awkward position.

915
00:38:46,616 --> 00:38:50,328
Tom, I promised Martha
I'd be home for supper at 6:00.

916
00:38:50,412 --> 00:38:51,621
Mrs. Fletcher said she'd--

917
00:38:52,581 --> 00:38:54,332
Ah.

918
00:38:54,791 --> 00:38:56,209
Oh.
So sorry to keep you waiting.

919
00:38:56,293 --> 00:38:57,419
I got held up.

920
00:38:57,502 --> 00:38:58,962
Not at all, Mrs. Fletcher.
No problem.

921
00:38:59,046 --> 00:39:00,297
Oscar, do you know
Jessica Fletcher?

922
00:39:00,380 --> 00:39:01,298
Oscar Ramsey.

923
00:39:01,381 --> 00:39:02,549
I know the lady by reputation.

924
00:39:02,632 --> 00:39:03,675
How do you do, Mr. Ramsey?

925
00:39:03,759 --> 00:39:04,718
Ma'am.

926
00:39:04,801 --> 00:39:06,678
Have you met Becky Anderson?

927
00:39:06,762 --> 00:39:08,263
Well, we haven't been
introduced.

928
00:39:08,346 --> 00:39:10,265
-Hello.
-Mrs. Fletcher.

929
00:39:10,348 --> 00:39:11,892
Got to say,
you people in the jury

930
00:39:11,975 --> 00:39:13,393
-didn't surprise me any.
-That so?

931
00:39:13,477 --> 00:39:15,896
I did figure you'd come in
sooner with the verdict.

932
00:39:15,979 --> 00:39:17,272
Well, we spent some time--

933
00:39:17,355 --> 00:39:20,859
Finding as you did, makes this
meetin' somewhat academic.

934
00:39:20,942 --> 00:39:23,236
However,
Tom said you'd explain.

935
00:39:23,320 --> 00:39:25,864
Well, Mr. Ramsey,
it's really simple.

936
00:39:25,947 --> 00:39:29,201
You see, it's our opinion,
that is, the jury's,

937
00:39:29,284 --> 00:39:32,204
that Becky Anderson
killed her husband.

938
00:39:32,287 --> 00:39:33,580
That's not true!

939
00:39:33,663 --> 00:39:35,207
What the hell is this?

940
00:39:35,290 --> 00:39:36,208
Hear her out, Oscar.

941
00:39:36,291 --> 00:39:38,710
It gets very interesting.

942
00:39:38,794 --> 00:39:40,378
It's a bunch of damn hogwash!

943
00:39:40,462 --> 00:39:42,631
The same evidence
that got the first verdict

944
00:39:42,714 --> 00:39:43,924
is gonna clear my client.

945
00:39:44,007 --> 00:39:47,552
Well, we didn't exactly
find on that evidence.

946
00:39:48,303 --> 00:39:49,513
You didn't what?

947
00:39:49,596 --> 00:39:51,389
Well, of course
it was the evidence

948
00:39:51,473 --> 00:39:54,392
and how we saw it
after some pushing and poking.

949
00:39:54,476 --> 00:39:57,145
One thing
we couldn't understand is

950
00:39:57,229 --> 00:40:00,440
what happened when your husband
arrived at your apartment.

951
00:40:00,524 --> 00:40:02,275
Mark explained that.

952
00:40:02,734 --> 00:40:04,861
Well, not to our satisfaction,
I'm afraid.

953
00:40:05,320 --> 00:40:08,031
In fact,
we feel that he was lying.

954
00:40:08,115 --> 00:40:09,241
No.

955
00:40:09,324 --> 00:40:10,617
I'm not gonna allow this.

956
00:40:10,700 --> 00:40:11,910
We are leavin'.

957
00:40:11,993 --> 00:40:13,912
You'll save us both
a lot of time and work

958
00:40:13,995 --> 00:40:16,915
if you stay and listen, Oscar.

959
00:40:16,998 --> 00:40:19,292
Mark's story
about struggling for the gun

960
00:40:19,376 --> 00:40:21,711
and wielding
the fireplace poker--

961
00:40:21,795 --> 00:40:24,714
Now, it really is so much
nonsense, considering

962
00:40:24,798 --> 00:40:28,260
that his collarbone injury
from the accident.

963
00:40:28,969 --> 00:40:30,887
I was there.
I saw it.

964
00:40:30,971 --> 00:40:32,764
Yes, you were there.

965
00:40:32,848 --> 00:40:34,891
But you didn't see anything.

966
00:40:34,975 --> 00:40:37,853
You're the one
who struck the fatal blow.

967
00:40:37,936 --> 00:40:40,147
While Mark stood by
and watched?

968
00:40:40,230 --> 00:40:42,482
No, we don't believe that
he was there when it happened.

969
00:40:42,566 --> 00:40:44,818
Really?

970
00:40:44,901 --> 00:40:47,237
And just where was he,
Mrs. Fletcher?

971
00:40:47,320 --> 00:40:49,823
He was at the hospital,
murdering his wife.

972
00:40:54,828 --> 00:40:57,455
Play Hail Columbia
and salute the flag!

973
00:40:57,539 --> 00:41:00,500
Will you listen to that!
[laughs]

974
00:41:00,584 --> 00:41:02,502
That is what happened,
isn't it, Becky?

975
00:41:02,586 --> 00:41:04,129
No.

976
00:41:04,212 --> 00:41:06,464
Isn't that why you refused
to take the lie detector test,

977
00:41:06,548 --> 00:41:08,466
because you were afraid
if you were asked

978
00:41:08,550 --> 00:41:11,344
if Mark had killed your husband
in self-defense

979
00:41:11,428 --> 00:41:12,470
and you answered yes,

980
00:41:12,554 --> 00:41:15,098
the machine would show
that you were lying?

981
00:41:15,182 --> 00:41:16,099
No!

982
00:41:16,183 --> 00:41:17,767
Not a shred of this will fly.

983
00:41:17,851 --> 00:41:19,728
You try usin' this in court,

984
00:41:19,811 --> 00:41:23,315
and I'll set your run
for state office back ten years.

985
00:41:23,398 --> 00:41:25,317
Oscar, we are not
talking politics here.

986
00:41:25,400 --> 00:41:27,235
We are talking
cold-blooded murder.

987
00:41:27,319 --> 00:41:29,529
Mark Reynolds had been
to the bide-a-wee motel

988
00:41:29,613 --> 00:41:31,281
at least six times.

989
00:41:31,364 --> 00:41:33,408
How many others
might he have gone to?

990
00:41:33,491 --> 00:41:35,076
And on the night
of his wife's dying,

991
00:41:35,160 --> 00:41:36,912
he picked up another woman
in a tavern.

992
00:41:36,995 --> 00:41:38,830
It was
an accidental encounter.

993
00:41:38,914 --> 00:41:41,875
A woman he'd been seen with
six weeks earlier.

994
00:41:41,958 --> 00:41:44,294
That testimony was refuted
by cross-examination.

995
00:41:44,377 --> 00:41:46,004
Not refuted,
merely challenged.

996
00:41:46,087 --> 00:41:47,255
Mrs. Fletcher,

997
00:41:47,339 --> 00:41:48,757
maybe you can make somethin'
like this

998
00:41:48,840 --> 00:41:50,217
work in one of your novels,

999
00:41:50,300 --> 00:41:52,385
but not in a court of law.

1000
00:41:52,469 --> 00:41:54,429
That was the first time I saw
him.

1001
00:41:54,512 --> 00:41:55,764
You heard the bartender.

1002
00:41:56,598 --> 00:41:57,807
And the bartender heard

1003
00:41:57,891 --> 00:42:00,185
what you and Mark
wanted him to hear.

1004
00:42:00,268 --> 00:42:02,187
The reason for
the accidental meeting was

1005
00:42:02,270 --> 00:42:05,732
to give Mark an alibi
from a so-called stranger.

1006
00:42:06,149 --> 00:42:07,859
His motive is clear.

1007
00:42:07,943 --> 00:42:09,903
He loved Becky.

1008
00:42:09,986 --> 00:42:11,988
His wife of less than a year
had all the money.

1009
00:42:12,072 --> 00:42:13,323
He wanted both.

1010
00:42:13,406 --> 00:42:15,742
Next thing you'll say
is the car accident

1011
00:42:15,825 --> 00:42:18,536
that damn near killed him
and his wife was deliberate.

1012
00:42:19,204 --> 00:42:20,705
Well, I believe that it was.

1013
00:42:20,789 --> 00:42:23,500
A former professional
race car driver?

1014
00:42:23,583 --> 00:42:26,253
He staged it so that
his wife would be killed.

1015
00:42:26,336 --> 00:42:27,254
He wore a seat belt.

1016
00:42:27,337 --> 00:42:28,505
She never did.

1017
00:42:28,588 --> 00:42:30,340
He slammed her side of the car

1018
00:42:30,423 --> 00:42:31,633
into that utility pole.

1019
00:42:31,716 --> 00:42:34,135
It was made-to-order murder.

1020
00:42:34,219 --> 00:42:38,098
Remember the paramedic
saying she asked "why?"

1021
00:42:38,181 --> 00:42:41,476
She was asking
why he tried to kill her.

1022
00:42:41,893 --> 00:42:43,895
The fact that
she didn't die on impact...

1023
00:42:43,979 --> 00:42:45,313
and the fact
that the doctor said

1024
00:42:45,397 --> 00:42:48,441
she could regain consciousness
and expose him

1025
00:42:48,525 --> 00:42:52,320
meant he had to quickly
improvise a foolproof alibi.

1026
00:42:52,404 --> 00:42:53,446
He called Becky.

1027
00:42:53,530 --> 00:42:56,324
Who else could he trust?

1028
00:42:56,408 --> 00:42:59,995
And what better alibi than
to be in bed with another woman?

1029
00:43:02,831 --> 00:43:03,915
She's wrong.

1030
00:43:03,999 --> 00:43:06,084
Mr. Ramsey,
you have to believe me.

1031
00:43:06,167 --> 00:43:07,502
It would have worked

1032
00:43:07,585 --> 00:43:10,547
except for
two unforeseen events.

1033
00:43:10,630 --> 00:43:13,883
First, was your being
remembered by the motel man.

1034
00:43:13,967 --> 00:43:15,552
The other
was your husband's learning

1035
00:43:15,635 --> 00:43:16,928
of your being in that tavern.

1036
00:43:17,012 --> 00:43:18,972
When he did, when he came home

1037
00:43:19,055 --> 00:43:21,641
to your house,
he found you alone.

1038
00:43:21,725 --> 00:43:25,103
Now, you couldn't let anyone
know Mark wasn't with you,

1039
00:43:25,186 --> 00:43:26,646
so you had to kill him.

1040
00:43:27,439 --> 00:43:28,732
That's not how it happened!

1041
00:43:28,815 --> 00:43:29,858
He was furious!
He had a gun--

1042
00:43:29,941 --> 00:43:31,109
Don't say any more!

1043
00:43:36,072 --> 00:43:38,408
I'm not going to
face this alone.

1044
00:43:38,491 --> 00:43:41,745
Miss Anderson,
don't incriminate yourself.

1045
00:43:41,828 --> 00:43:43,079
If she wants to cooperate,
Oscar,

1046
00:43:43,163 --> 00:43:44,414
we could cut a deal...

1047
00:43:44,497 --> 00:43:46,458
if the husband's death
really was self-defense.

1048
00:43:47,625 --> 00:43:50,211
Even if Mrs. Fletcher's
right...

1049
00:43:50,295 --> 00:43:51,755
and my client and Reynolds

1050
00:43:51,838 --> 00:43:53,423
were mixed up
in his wife's murder,

1051
00:43:53,506 --> 00:43:55,675
she could plead second degree
in the wife's death.

1052
00:43:58,845 --> 00:44:00,889
I want Mark Reynolds.

1053
00:44:03,850 --> 00:44:04,893
Becky?

1054
00:44:10,940 --> 00:44:12,067
All right.

1055
00:44:13,735 --> 00:44:15,945
Tell us the entire story.

1056
00:44:21,534 --> 00:44:23,119
I was alone.

1057
00:44:25,330 --> 00:44:28,958
Mark had been gone
a half hour, 40 minutes

1058
00:44:29,042 --> 00:44:31,378
by the time Cliff came.

1059
00:44:31,461 --> 00:44:33,713
He was in a rage.

1060
00:44:33,797 --> 00:44:36,758
He said all sorts of--

1061
00:44:36,841 --> 00:44:38,385
He was horrible. Ugly.

1062
00:44:38,468 --> 00:44:40,553
He had a gun.

1063
00:44:40,637 --> 00:44:43,264
He wouldn't believe I was alone.

1064
00:44:43,890 --> 00:44:46,726
And when he found out I was,
he demanded to know...

1065
00:44:46,810 --> 00:44:48,520
who the man was
and where he was.

1066
00:44:48,603 --> 00:44:50,939
He swore he'd kill him...

1067
00:44:51,022 --> 00:44:52,649
and me.
I--

1068
00:44:53,733 --> 00:44:56,444
The poker was in my hand.

1069
00:44:56,528 --> 00:44:58,113
And I hit him.

1070
00:45:01,324 --> 00:45:02,534
He fell.

1071
00:45:03,952 --> 00:45:08,289
It was a--
a half hour maybe,

1072
00:45:08,373 --> 00:45:11,709
maybe more when--
when Mark came back.

1073
00:45:13,002 --> 00:45:15,547
He said it was made-to-order.

1074
00:45:15,630 --> 00:45:16,631
A foolproof alibi.

1075
00:45:18,299 --> 00:45:21,428
He'd confess to killing Cliff
in self-defense and--

1076
00:45:23,638 --> 00:45:25,557
and that way no one would
have the slightest hint

1077
00:45:25,640 --> 00:45:27,767
that he'd killed his wife
in cold blood.

1078
00:45:29,853 --> 00:45:32,730
And to make certain that it
looked like self-defense,

1079
00:45:32,814 --> 00:45:34,899
he saw to it that his
fingerprints

1080
00:45:34,983 --> 00:45:36,818
were on the poker...

1081
00:45:37,402 --> 00:45:40,071
and that the powder traces
were on his left hand.

1082
00:45:41,322 --> 00:45:43,450
So with the bullet
fired into the wall,

1083
00:45:43,533 --> 00:45:47,162
all that was left was
for you to call the police.

1084
00:45:51,499 --> 00:45:53,084
He said it was easy

1085
00:45:53,168 --> 00:45:56,212
to sneak into
his wife's hospital room.

1086
00:45:58,548 --> 00:46:01,509
A pillow over her face--

1087
00:46:05,138 --> 00:46:08,433
As weak as she was,
she died almost instantly.

1088
00:46:20,487 --> 00:46:21,488
The deal holds, Oscar,

1089
00:46:21,571 --> 00:46:23,865
but I'll need her
on the witness stand.

1090
00:46:25,116 --> 00:46:26,701
She'll be there.

1091
00:46:40,715 --> 00:46:43,009
-Ah, Mrs. Fletcher.
-Oh, Mr. Reynolds.

1092
00:46:44,511 --> 00:46:47,472
How can I thank you
for your verdict?

1093
00:46:47,555 --> 00:46:48,473
There's no need.

1094
00:46:48,556 --> 00:46:49,849
The satisfaction is knowing

1095
00:46:49,933 --> 00:46:51,935
that the right thing
has been done.

1096
00:46:52,936 --> 00:46:55,855
Nevertheless,
I just want you to know

1097
00:46:55,939 --> 00:46:57,106
I'll always remember you.

1098
00:46:57,690 --> 00:46:59,484
Oh, yes.

1099
00:46:59,567 --> 00:47:01,694
I'm quite sure you will.

1100
00:47:07,283 --> 00:47:10,286
[all murmuring]


